Independent reviews · Evidence first

Wearing a Shoulder Sling: Comfort Tips From Reddit Owners

Based on 2,689 Reddit comments that mention this topic, 2,016 of them first-hand (the commenter describes their own experience). Sources: r/RotatorCuff, r/ShoulderInjuries, r/ShoulderSurgery, r/Orthopedics, r/frozenshoulder. Last updated 2026-11-19.

Shoulder.io summarizes what owners report on Reddit. It is not medical advice and none of these products treats or cures an injury. For shoulder pain, see a doctor or physical therapist.

After surgery or a shoulder injury, many people spend weeks in a sling. Owners trade notes on neck straps, abduction pillows, sleeping in the sling and when it finally comes off.

The short version

Rated by simple keyword rules, of the 876 first-hand comments with a clear positive or negative tone, 70% are positive and 30% are critical. The themes people bring up most are sleeping in it (602), abduction pillow (338), coming off (317). These are reports from individual Reddit users, not medical guidance, and experiences vary a lot from person to person.

Representative first-hand comments

The most-upvoted first-hand excerpts that passed our quote filters, from different commenters. Each links to the full comment.

showering and dressingcoming off
“The hospital staff didn't even want to help me change my clothes and left me by myself to take off the sling and put it back on, on my own.”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-07-23
coming off
“I drove for 20 minutes this morning (first time driving since mid June) and my arm was fatigued and sore after, put the sling back on for a bit when I got home.”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-08-03
“The first 6 weeks are terrible in the sling but it gets better if you are patient and then one day you just realize you don’t even think it about it anymore.”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-07-03
neck strapsleeping in it
“The sling was also already on when they woke me up. I think I actually stayed in that shirt for the first couple of days until I could shower.”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-08-09
“I'm very far from when I started but those 5 weeks in the sling I thought I was never going to feel normal again.”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-05-29
coming off
“I was using my sling hand from probably day 3, onward, increasing how much I used it. At first it would just hold things, then with increasing grip, then increasing force.”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-05-18

Themes in first-hand comments

Counted with keyword rules across first-hand comments; one comment can touch several themes.

Sleeping in it · 602 first-hand mentions

sleeping in it
“I was in the sling 24/7 for 6 weeks and 2 more weeks when sleeping and in public. I’ve been in PT twice a week since the first of May and work out at home 4-5 times a week (stretching, multi-gym, rowing, occasional Peloton bike).”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-01-14

Abduction pillow · 338 first-hand mentions

abduction pillow
“Everyone is different, but my surgeon is allowing me to be out of my sling resting on my pillow on the sofa at day two”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-09-19

Coming off · 317 first-hand mentions

coming off
“I weaned myself off the sling when he told me I could go without it, like 30 min or an hour at a time until it gradually became more comfortable to be without it than with it.”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-09-21

Showering and dressing · 271 first-hand mentions

showering and dressing
“That being said I can take off and put on my sling. I got a mesh shower sling off Amazon to support my arm Spray deodorant, pump shampoo and conditioner.”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-07-29

Neck strap · 179 first-hand mentions

neck strap
“Also helpful for others: you do NOT have to use the sling they give you. I ordered one online that had the correct abduction pillow for the correct angle and all that but was MUCH more comfortable because it took the weight off my neck and moved it to the opposite shoulder.”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-02-22

Sweat and skin · 85 first-hand mentions

sweat and skin
“After soaking my sling with sweat on the hottest day of the year earlier this week, I decided to buy a second sling so I can wash/rotate them.”
comment via r/RotatorCuff · 2026-07-17

Products owners name in these threads

Models we track that come up by name in these comments. Each links to its full owner-score page.

DonJoy

DonJoy UltraSling III

4.2 (6 owner comments)

$71.91 (price as of 2026-11-08)

sleepcomfort

“If they give you a Don Joy sling that wraps around your neck (standard issue) here is an identical one that wraps around opposite shoulder.”

Read review →
Breg

Breg SlingShot 3 Shoulder Brace

2.6 (5 owner comments)

$168.99 (price as of 2026-11-19)

sleepvalue

“My surgeon put me in a BREG SlingShot 2.”

Read review →

How we built this page

We searched 2,689 public Reddit comments from a 12-month archive for this topic, kept first-hand comments, and grouped them by recurring themes with keyword rules. Quotes are short excerpts that link to the original comment; we skip quotes that discuss medication or make health claims. Read the full methodology.

Keep reading

All posture & shoulder supportIce Machines After Shoulder SurgerySleeping After Shoulder SurgeryOver-the-Door Shoulder PulleysHeating Pads & Ice Packs for Shoulder DiscomfortTENS UnitsFoam Rollers & Lacrosse BallsWhat to Wear After Shoulder SurgeryDaily-Living Aids for Shoulder RecoveryAll guidesMethodology